He Askes Her In New Moon At The End And Properly Proposes Like Down On One Knee With A Answer Until Eclipse And He Gets A YES !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! TeeHee
ECLIPSE!!!!! ^^^^^^^^^^^^but he never "officialy proposed to her like he berkata in eclipse with the speech and one knee and ring stuff. that was all in eclipse
ECLIPSE!; "isabella swan, i promise to cinta anda forever, every single hari of forever. will anda marry me?" in new moon, where he says "marry me first", it was lebih of a command than a proposal. =/
In New Moon Edward asked Bella to marry him but that is when they started all the conditions with him changing her and getting married, but she didn't want to get married yet so she was just going to have Carlisle change her. In Eclipse he proposed again going along with the conditions topic again and she berkata yes that time :]