So I Was A Little Dissipionted With The Elcipse Movie! It Wasn't Very Loyal To The Book! There Were A Lot Of Scenes They Didn't Have! Did Anyone Feel The Same Way?

What scenes do anda feel they left out? I thought they did a pretty good job with keeping in pivotal scenes.

U knw.. It is not psbl to screen all the scenes from book.. And so mixed the scene for staying the sense of the story... So,,... It happens...

I was disappointed too, I think New Moon translated better to screen then Eclipse. But Eclipse was 10x better than Twilight, for sure.

The scenes switched way to quickly! I wanted there to be a lot lebih lines from the book! I had high expectations and I was let down!

I ENJOYED IT . I THOUGHT THEY DID MUCH BETTER THEN THE PERVIOUS TWO ,, THEY SHOWED ALOT OF IMPORTANT SENCES BUT IT IS LIMITED IN TIME . I FELT LIKE NEW MOON WAS RUSHED AND DID NOT tampil ANYTHING IMPORTANT SO I AM REALLY HAPPY WITH ECLIPSE AND I KNOW BREAKING DAWN WILL BE EVEN BETTER :)

yeah. i thought the same thing, 2 when i 1st saw the movie, personally i like the book better, but the movie was good 2.

Yeah, I felt like I couldn't keep up that much. They jumped from scene to scene too quickly! I mean, it's awesome that they included the newborn scenes that we couldn't see in the movie, but at times I felt like I was seeing a movie based off of 'The Short detik Life of Bree Tanner' lebih than Eclipse. If they had taken some newborn army scenes out, maybe they would have some time to put the scenes we pictured while membaca the book.

I wasnt disappointed because i read all the blogs and knew what scenes werent in there, but i think they included much lebih than i expected. The only two that i really kind of missed was the Alice kidnapping scene and the end when Jacob gets the invite and runs away. I did also feel that the scenes moved so fast, thats why i didnt go to the midnight showing. I remember how they did that in the other 2 and it would have diberikan me a headache. secara keseluruhan, keseluruhan it was good, much better than Twilight, a little better than New Moon since most(notall) of the background scenery looked real this time.

sooooo true i was really disappointed with it and it was my fav book and i dont know i think it wasnt worth our hype and all i would give it 4 out of 10 it was only worth watching that is not lebih then that

its so true. I thought that the movie was great but it just left out some scenes that I considered rather important. e.g.:the time when Bella are not allowed to see Jacob, and Bella wandered around in the forest, worried abt Edward and Jacob.

i agree it is a little stupid the book way bettetr

Meh, I thought the movie was good!

I agree with you. I expected to see the scenes that I smiled when I was membaca but there weren't any. For instance, the scene when Bella got in her truck to go see Jake but the truck won't start because Edward's got a part of the vehicle in his hand and he's like Looking for this? I thought that moment was really funny and it didn't give the same feeling in the movie. A lot of the dialogues between Alice and Bella were missing. We can't get to see how humorous Alice is. The scenes of Jacob were nothing like I imagined. I think if anda don't read the buku and only watch the movies, anda can never understand why Bella likes Jacob so much. Every scene of Bella and Jacob was painful to watch because it was like there was no passion between them.
What I'm trying to say is that those funny lines in the book were missing. They were what made the book so great to me.

of course the book is going to be better. Thats just what happens when a book is being adapted into a film. If they kept EVERY little detail- the film would be hours and hours long! I think they kept the key scenes true to the book and did a good job of adapting the smaller thing to fit the movie version. secara keseluruhan, keseluruhan i enjoyed it the most out of the 3 so far. Though with BD being 2 parts im sure they'll be able to keep in all the little details! :)