Odette Yustman -Melanie

WBkinder she could be cool as Mel, but on the other pictures I've seen of er, she sort of looks too old than 20 years.

lilchas She she my pick too! I love her and think she would be absoultly perfect. WBkinder she is only 24...I don't think its that bad really. If you think about it alot of times in movies they cast people alot older than that for teenage roles.

hostinhostess Yeah I like her, she seems young enough to be melanie and she has the right kind of features

LillyJane I'm really not a fan of Odette, I think she's too old and not a good enough actress to play Mel. My money's on Hannah Taylor Gordon for the part of Melanie http://content1.catalog.photos.msn.com/ft/share0/2ae3/0/5791079.jpg She's just perfect for the part!

Culygirly I think this girl is a beautiful Melanie. I looked at the picture of Hannah Taylor Gordon LillyJane linked and no way...this girl has her way beat! The quesiton is ...can she act? Looks are one thing ...but this role is the main character and needs to have good acting skills.

nicole62 She a good actress. She started acting at a very young age. She was one of the kids in Kindergarten Cop. I really liked her in Cloverfield.

VictoriaAlice She is the closest I've found to what I imagined Mel as. But I have a friend who looks just like what I thought Mel would look like…except…she's only 14…so obviously way too young. But other than that, she looks just like her!

kuncuyug I think the same. She looks closest to Mel.