I thought it was adorable that here he is all suspicious of her...but that sure as hell isn't gonna keep him from chowing down on the pie! lol

I know it's a bit late response to the eppy but I can't stop thinking about it!While I was watching it, I was hoping that Dean wouldn't eat the apple-pie from the zombie!And when he ate it and liked it(!!!!!) I was shocked!Dean your appetite has to have some boundaries....at least some basic ones....no apple-pies or burgers from zombies!Man, John screwed up this kid!!:D

On a related note- remember in the epi 'A Very Supernatural Christmas', they go hunting pagan gods and one of them offers the boys some peanut brittle- Dean reaches out to take some and Sam slaps his hand down! LOL The boy loves his food! XDD

true facts.

twas' cherry :D hence the red filing. *nods* (: bahaha.

^^Actually, the first pie was apple. The one he ate in the kitchen with Karen was cherry. :)

I loved Sammy's face when he was looking at Dean and Dean so innocent like "what? it's delicious" :D

lol i felt the same as fanfly: "I thought it was adorable that here he is all suspicious of her...but that sure as hell isn't gonna keep him from chowing down on the pie!"
and i love the part about reaching for the pagan gods' peanut brittle too XD

DAMN now i really want some pie !!!! XD

and i think the first scene it is apple pie: link & link

and then in the kitchen it looks like he's eating cherry link and she is making multiple kinds of pie (some look like they have dark filling and some light) link

I thought it was cute. Dean loves pie. Zombie made or not XD

It was cute, but as well as his love for pie, I think it was actually also out of politeness (if thats a word lol) cos she actually was a sweet lady (despite the zombie part) and i think he was just trying to be polite cos as soon as she'd left the room, he pushed it away slightly... but still that boy loves his pie =P

I thought it was cute too. And like everyone has said, he really does love his food :)

*laughs* ally, you pie expert xD

i don't think it was anything wrong with eating a pie made of a zombie. after all she was aware of that she was a zombie, and she would never hurt either bobby or the boys :)