Colin O'Donoghue Won't Guest bintang on Outlander… Yet 

5 Things to Watch Today – July 3, 2018

Why you should watch The Bold Type, Face Off and more

5 Things to Watch Today – July 11, 2017

For one glorious hour this morning (July 3), it look like

fans were going to get treated to one of the best cameos of all time. Sadly, it turned out Colin O\'Donoghue, Caitriona Balfe and Sam Heughan were just being adorable Twitter dorks.

Season 4 wrapped up its final days of filming, Caitriona Balfe tweeted her thanks to all the people who\'d made this season a success — including one actor we never expected to show up in the rolling hills of 18th Century Scotland: Colin O\'Donoghue.

Twitter naturally went into a tizzy, wondering whether this meant a special guest role was on the way, but O\'Donoghue quickly chimed in that he thought there had been some mistake. Damn you, Colin, can\'t you just let us have this one?! An embarrassed Balfe confirmed the error, saying she\'d meant to tag a different Colin in her tweet. Unfortunately, the Internet is forever, and more Outlander cast members decided to get in on the joke.

"Christ... You kept that quiet mate. Welcome to

," Richard Rankin, who plays Roger Wakefield, tweeted.

"Thank you anyway Colin. You\'ve kept us going... from afar!" Sam Heughan joked.

4 Tips for Surviving "Droughtlander" From Caitriona Balfe and Sam Heughan

While this was obviously just a hilarious gaffe, it\'s not like there isn\'t a good reason for fans to think O\'Donoghue might have shown up in

\'s upcoming season. For one, he\'s been friendly with the cast for a long time, so it wouldn\'t exactly be difficult for him to snag a role as a rascally Irishman should the opportunity arise. Second, now that

has officially come to an end, O\'Donoghue is free to pursue new roles he wouldn\'t have previously had the availability for while he was working a full time gig as Captain Hook.

If you\'re holding out hope you might see your favorite pirate one day on

, O\'Donoghue and Heughan haven\'t ruled the possibility out entirely.

"Hahah well... there\'s always season5!? #irishMafia," Heughan tweeted to which O\'Donoghue responded, "Anytime!"

You Can Now Watch Starz Shows on YouTube TVA Starz upgrade is available from YouTube\'s cable alternative

At Long Last, Outlander Is Headed to New York Comic ConThe NYCC Droughtlander is finally over!

Hallelujah! Outlander Gets a Two-Season Renewal at StarzLet\'s get settled in America!

Once Upon a Time: Young Henry Was Yet Again the Key to Breaking the CurseBut he\'s not the only familiar face to return

You Can Watch Westworld Season 1 Without an HBO SubscriptionAs long as you\'re a subscriber to one of the biggest cable companies

4 Tips for Surviving "Droughtlander" From Caitriona Balfe and Sam HeughanDon\'t forget your personal needs!

Like Us to Get More Entertainment News from TV Guide

© 2018 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved.

Photo Credits: David Bloomer; John Medland, Freeform; Myles Aronowitz/Starz; Jeff Weddell, ABC; John P. Johnson/HBO; Casey Crafford