how is cheating on brooke worse than cheating on lindsey? Cause it hit the fans harder (brucas fans especially). I'm no lundsey fan, but I chose this one cause although cheating on brooke was a royal screw-up, he wasn't in love with her. He was in love with lindsey and still kissed peyton and strung her along in the process. He then proposed to lindsey on the same night. He treated two girls like crap that night. At least when he cheated on brooke, it was 1 girl he screwed over.

2nd place goes to letting peyton go the second time. the first time was out of his control. It was best that they called it quits for brooke's sake. at least till things blew over.

He was such an ASS!!!

he cheated on brooke with her best friends so thats worse than with lindsey i cant belive you would pick that over what he did to brooke TWICE

what he did was really fucked up

that was harsh i gotta say

livelovelaugh, I know you're a brooke/brucas fan, but if the situations were reversed (brucas were as serious in s1 as lundsey was in s5) you'd be agreeing with me right now. Luke even said "I didn't have feelings for you then." and luke was gonna tell brooke the truth, but she found out before hand. Luke was willing to marry lindsey when he had just kissed peyton on the same night. and Luke didn't cheat on brooke a second time. The library thing was blown completely out of proportion. It wasn't a romantic moment. It was two friends saying a potential goodbye should Lucas fail to save Peyton's life. but when luke accidentally told Brooke about it, it reopened old wounds for her from s1; so her insecurities got the best of her. That's it. I know brooke loved luke. but luke LOVED lindsey and lindsey loved him back. They were living together for pete's sake. If you can't see the difference, I dunno what to tell you, lol. Guess we'll agree to disagree :)
wouldn't be the first time, lol.

abs07 i do see where your coming from it was horrible but im a brucas fan naturally im gonna pick that and naturally your gonna pick your choice its jus natural if ya no wat i mean but brooke new wahta she was getting into the second time round and lindsey didnt i think peyton should have nown better considering what happend the first time but its not her fault shes jus inlove and i do agree the second time was stupid i dont realy think it was cheating either

to clarify, I didn't make this option cause i'm a leyton fan. Luke screwed two girls over in this scenario; and the way he did it was shocking.

but I appreciate your honesty, livelovelaugh :)

this was really messed up. i dont see how his mind went from kissing peyton back to proposing to lindsey. i mean i saw what happened in the episode (with lindsey finding the ring herself) but its not good enough.

it was a seriously dick move.

ps im really glad that you two (abs07 and livelovelaugh) could talk about the issue reasonably unlike so many other people here. you guys rock!

:)

or almost marrying lindsey...

eeerrrgggg that made me sooo mad! i leyton 4 ever

& letting her go

He's an idiot..LOL