I hated when Peyton was awful to Brooke over the Nathan thing. And even though Peyton's been so hurtful in the past, Brooke still ended up being the bigger person and saved her life from psycho Derek.

she cheated on brooke , TWICE now

Jessica4695 I wouldn`t call that cheating yes she kissed Lucas in the library but she was willing to make her feelings for Lucas go away if Brooke asked her to. Sounds like a pretty good friend to me.

They both weren't that awesome. The worst thing was Brooke laughing @ Peyton's mother death & Peyton kissing Lucas, again.

^Ooo I'd forgotten about Brooke being mean about Peyton's mom dying. I'm blinded by Brooke adoration, lol.

This was definitely the worse one :/

They both did bad stuff to each other, people are always talking about how Peyton is a bad friend because she kissed Luke, but as much as I love Brooke, she did stuff to Peyton too, like when she laughed at her mother's death, that was HORRIBLE!

What matters is that they are now best friends! <33

Although that Peyton is out of the picture...LMAO!

I love that friendship but end of season 3 and part of season 4 was a hard time for them.I think they're both to blame(one more than the other) but they were both at fault and I'm glad they got through it and built a stronger friendship.It's just sad that we can't see the continuation of that roller coaster friendship! Breyton4ever!

season one as bad yeah because they argued. But in season 4 it really seemed like they didnt want to make up at all. Like brooke said at least if she was mad she'd still care.
Breyton always argue though -its part of their rocky friendship which makes them so great!
breyton always xx

"like before is gone" soo true. this fight reinforced my dislike of breyton, true friends dont really behave the way brooke and peyton did. its just annoying and ridiculous.