Don't get me wrong, i would CRY and stop watchin if they killed off peyton, but i'm just curious..

guys..NOTICE it says FAKE SCENARIO! i don't actually think this is gonna happen.

I don't think they is any way they would kill of Peyton and number two he would take it pretty bad I think it would be even worse if this happened more than Keith. If Peyton died Lucas wouldn't be the only one who would be in bad shape. Brooke would be pretty bad two. If they kill off Peyton the ratings are gonna sink she is one of the main characters and we know what happens when you kill off a main character when it is not a series finale ex the oc.

OF COURSE HE WOULD!
OMFG! That's not a fake scenario..that's a disaster,nightmare-scenario!LOL! Plus Mark would have to be totally drugged to write such a crap!

^ lmao! :) ... lets hope it never happens :P

lol never gonna happen. i mean you can't kill off any of the main 5, cuz then it wouldn't be one tree hill.

I'm a BL shipper, but I know that he would take it hard.
I'm not going to lie because of my preference.
I mean, he asked the girl to marry him twice (if not more) and they have such a history and he was in love with her... but, Brooke and him would both suffer equally in my opinion. But, I don't want Peyton to die, because I think that would throw away a chance for brucas, not bring one back. Because Brooke would feel like she was betraying Peyton and all of that...
Plus, I like Peyton! I don't want her to go.
I just don't think her and Lucas are right for eachother.
I tried, but I failed.
Brucas Shipper Forever.

I think it would be harder for him. Peyton is the love of his life, and it would be hard for him to let go of that love. With Keith, it was a different love, but not one that he NEEDED, although Keith was very important to him. I think he'd also feel way more guilty... Cos he would've wished he'd said yes in LA 3 years ago probably so that they could've had more time.
But seriously, if Peyton died, One Tree Hill would die with her.

1treehillfan i totally get it..i mean, i don't think that brucas is meant for eachother at all, and i don't understand how you can think that leyton don't belong together, but thats just me..i do get what ur saying though

Shes the love of his life. Thats the hardest thing to loose apart from your Mom and Dad. Keith was important to him, sure, but Peyton's different. He loved Keith as an uncle. He is in love with Peyton so its completely different =D x

im not a leyton fan...but of course he would have such a hard time if she died. i mean its different when keith died cause he was like a father to him, but whether hes in love with peyton or not- shes one of his closest friends. brooke nathan and haley would also have a REALLY hard time...thats what it means when you care about someone!