Would anda Consider Brooke a Bad friend for not telling Peyton about the attack? poling Results - one pohon bukit, hill

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

one tree hill Would anda Consider Brooke a Bad friend for not telling Peyton about the attack?

105 fans picked:

No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade

89%

Yes she is and this wasn't the only time she has been I'll tell anda in komentar

11%

dermer4ever posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu

Make your pick! | next poll >>

22 comments

	1treehillfan picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: I would call her A GOOD friend for letting the issue be and just trying to not concern anyone else with it. She just wants Peyton to be happy with Lucas and she's trying to make sure that no one is bothered by it. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	huggies picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: I think she wants to be strong enough on her own this time. I can understand her motives for not telling Peyton even though I don't necessarily agree with them. I deffo would not call her a bad friend. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	tvfan5 picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: she is a good friend, as shown in season 5 especially. I wish she had told peyton, I REALLY DO. i think that she feels it is better if she just goes through it alone, but it isn't. hopefully peyton finds out about it soon, so she can be there for brooke, like brooke was there for peyton. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	BrookeYourself picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: i agree with tvfan5 but i understand she didn't tell peyton couse she's so happy now with lucas! posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu. last edited lebih dari setahun yang lalu

	SG1-090 picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: No, just like i wouldn't call P.Sawyer a bad friend for not being psychic and knowing what happened to Brooke. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	dermer4ever picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: I agree with all of you. Brooke just wants to be able to deal with this on her own but that shouldn't be the way to do it. I agree with SG1 about Peyton if you ask me Peyton is god damn good friend. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	alessandra_28 picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: I think she was trying to be a good friend cuz she saw peyton happy for once and she didn't wanted to ruin it with her problems. I agree with you SG1, P. Sawyer is not a bad friedn either. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	misshenriksen picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: Brooke is a damn good friend, though i don't agree with her desicion.. I really hope she tells Peyton soon :( And I really hate it when people bash peyton just because she can't read people's minds. They are both VERY good friends to eachoter, specially the last two seasons :) posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	saBRUCAS picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: Brooke is the BEST friend ever! I dont get how Peyton believed Brooke...swear to god I thought the first lie was more believable than the second one! How could Peyton not get it. But I really love that Brooke is being strong about it all and not like Peyton. I dare anyone to pick the second choice! posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu. last edited lebih dari setahun yang lalu

	LeytonTLA picked Yes she is and this wasn't the only time she has been I'll tell anda in komentar: I've picked it... Now what? You gonna yell at me cause of that? I think you wrote the second choice so it looks bad if someone pick that not the other one... I actually don't think she's a bad friend,i think she's a great friend... But in this case i just don't like her decision... So i had to pick this one... posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	CatarinaSantos picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: It's your opinion LeytonTLA , of course we all need to respect that. But remember like or not Brooke decision is different that tell Brooke is a bad friend. For me , Brooke don't tell peyton to protect her and her happiness with Lucas. How this is being a bad friend? posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	LeytonTLA picked Yes she is and this wasn't the only time she has been I'll tell anda in komentar: Please be nice and read my answer again,somewhere in the end i said I THINK SHE'S A GREAT FRIEND... I knew it would be like this,you only see/read what you want to see/read... posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	CatarinaSantos picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: "It's your opinion LeytonTLA , of course we all need to respect that" , i tottaly respect your opinion , how nice i can be ? :) I show you my point of view . Only that , You said that you don't like Brooke decision , well i think the same way . But for me it's bad for Brooke not for Peyton . Peyton is happy with the guy she love , We are different people , we see things from a different way . It's normal :) posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu. last edited lebih dari setahun yang lalu

	1treehillfan picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: misshenriksen- I hate it when people bash Peyton too for that stuff, and I hate it when people bash Brooke or Haley(hales especially). But, don't take it so personally, because when people dislike the character, they will find ANY reason to bash them. :) And, this at leytonTLA, catrinasantos IS being nice. She was being really polite, she was just disagreeing with your answer, and that is the point for this spot. Clean, respectable debate :) I think your the one being a bit mean... And, personally, I agree with her. Just because you don't agree with Brooke's decision doesn't mean that that made her a worser friend because of it. I think she was TRYING to be a good friend, even if it wasn't the best decision in some people's opinions. I just don't understand how you think that makes her a worser friend. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	CatarinaSantos picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: thanks 1trehillfan . :) i was really trying be nice , i just have a different opinion. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	1treehillfan picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: ^^ Yeah, sometimes the debates can get intense :D And call me alice :) posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu. last edited lebih dari setahun yang lalu

	lucysmileyface picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: she saw her friend happy after such a long time so she kept it for herself..but i wish she had told peyton cuz who else than her could understand it better? posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	misshenriksen picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: ^^ exactly :) posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	brattynemz picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: She doesn't want anybody else involved. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	3liiiiin picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: I don't think that has nothing to do with her being a bad friend. Sure she should have told Peyton the truth, but honestly it would only make Peyton worried and make no good. So this more makes her a good friend than a bad friend if you understand what I meen :) posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	Imogenpark picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: Corse it doesnt make her a bad friend. guess she just didn't ant anyone to know. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.

	saBRUCAS picked No she isn't she just didn't want to be pitied atau rain on P.sawyer's parade: LeytonTLA its pretty sad that you picked the second option just because I dared someone to pick it...haha. Seriously I was only kidding with that because I dont think her trying to be nice to Peyton and protecting Peyton is her being a bad friend....but thats just me. posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu.