jawab pertanyaan ini

lost Pertanyaan

The Pearl, what was it's true purpose?

It was built before The angsa, swan was (Swan still being constructed in 1977, Pearl built 1971 - 73) so it's initial purpose could not have been monitoring those in The Swan, atau vice versa, nor monitoring those in The Pearl from The Flame.

Although Eko and Locke assume it is for monitoring those in The Swan, Locke later discovers it can view other stations, so Pierre Chang may have been referring to another station's work as a "phsycological experiment in progress".
 The Pearl, what was it's true purpose?
 PkmnTrainerJ posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu
next question »

lost Jawaban

gregaus said:
The answer to this pertanyaan lies in the orientation video for the Pearl. The angsa, swan was built after 1977 (the tahun of the Incident) and it was after this time that the Pearl became a monitoring station for the angsa, swan (ie the 'psychological experiment').

However this video is heavily edited (bits are cut out, re-spliced, extreme close ups of Pierre's eyebrows) and despite the 'copyright 1980' stamp at the end of the video, it's clear it was originally made prior to the incident as Pierre Chang does not have a prosthetic left arm. He has full use of both arms and hands when he places the notebook in the pneumatic tube.

Further evidence is the errrr... 'fashion' he was wearing. It's clearly early 70's style and not 1980 at all.

It's this 1980 'edit' that we've seen but even with these edits, it's clear it was a monitoring station before this. Just not for the angsa, swan station which was yet to exist.

I know you're asking 'but wait, then why is the angsa, swan station seen in one of the video screens behind Chang?'. Good question. It was green-screened in oleh whomever edited it using the latest post-1980 technology to make it seem newer. For all we know, it was done in the 90's atau later!!!

But it could NOT have been the angsa, swan that was playing in the background when Chang first recorded it in the early 70's because quite simply, it did not exist and Chang still had use of his left hand.

So while the "1980" version has a somewhat sinister tone (aka psyche experiment on the poor people in the angsa, swan pressing buttons every 108 mins), I do believe it probably was a general monitoring station observing several other stations (we know it was linked to several of them) and recording behaviour of people at those stations for the very reasons that Chang mentions.


CHANG: Station five, atau the Pearl, is a monitoring station where the activities of participants in DHARMA Initiative projects can be observed and recorded; not only for posterity but for the ongoing refinement of the initiative as a whole. As Karen DeGroot herself has written, "careful observation is the only key to true and complete awareness".


The real pertanyaan then is, who made the 1980 'edit' and why? Was it Dharma atau the Others??? *insert dramatic music*

select as best answer
posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu 
*
Whoa! Good answer dude. I hadn't seen this orientation video in ages. At least not paid such close attention to it before. I agree, I think the true purpose was exactly what Chang says. Here's what I want to know. Why the extreme close ups and lebih importantly, why are his eyebrows so totally uneven? His right eyebrow is lifted permanently and in the close ups, it looks like it was done with make up, kinda like how they draw eyebrows on Vulcans in bintang Trek. Part of his real brow is covered in make up and a new one drawn above it. Not even trying to be funny either. Seems extremely odd. Was it the Dharma make up team atau the lost make up team that did this for affect?
hawking posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu
*
I thought the eyebrow thing was make up as well but I did a google image cari on the actor François Chau, and it seems that's the natural shape of his eyebrows. There's even a hand drawn caricature of him with this brow feature being quite prominent!
gregaus posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu
*
link
gregaus posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu
*
Oops. Feel bad for bringing it up now, but in the orientation video, those extreme close ups are almost designed to bring attention to it.
hawking posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu
next question »