Both are gorgeous but Giselle has better eys, lips, and hair.

sweet big eyes VS cat-like sweet eyes -GISELLE WINS
thick, red hair VS dreamy orange-like, thin yet fine hair -GISELLE WINS
thin, red lips VS pink, fair sized lips -GISELLE WINS!!!

overall winner- GISELLE

Giselle even wins in clothing...

Giselle is plainly pretty and Ariel is not pretty. Giselle has really beautiful hair though

I'm sorry, Ariel. I really think Ariel is STUNNING but GISELLE...I would cut off my hand for that hair! She has the best animated hair of all time. Long, flowy, straight but a perfect wave to make it interesting. The flowers in her hair..Whoa! I need to shut up. She has a cute smile and lovely eyes.

wow KataraLover finds someone prettier than Ariel??? the world is definitely ending in December

Only slightly...

Ariel is prettier.

I love Ariel, but Giselle is prettier

her hair is gorgeous and her eyes are prettier

I'm surprised she isn't winning... anyway, I like her eyes a bit better, as well as her lips, nose, and hair.

OMG Why would you put them both on this!! T_T

Both are gorgeous, but I prefer Giselle's more natural appearance.

From what I've seen of Giselle, she looks sorta weird? She has the same skinny syndrome thing Ariel has where she looks way too spindly for her hugeass head but it sort of fits Ariel more...? I mean she's a fucking mermaid, you'd expect her to look weird.

I don't really like Giselle's nose :/. Her hair is gorgeous, though.