Matt smith may have better episodes (More money ect) But david had some really touching scenes, funny senes and everything you would expect on an awesome show..

They are both really amazing!

Its soooo hard to choose but i thought David Tennant had some very good and emotional episodes which he played so well i also feel he connected with the audience better so we will have to see how Matt Smith does :)

David, of course, but Matt is great too. :)

I stopped watching Doctor Who coz I really couldn't stand Matt Smith.

As soon as Matt went on Dr Who I stoped watching the show. Tom Baker is the best doctor followed by david

david is by far the better doctor . i watch 5 mis of matt simth as the doctor and he was crap havet watch it since come back david.

Oh David said he`d` come back(and he better).

the new stuff is ****. they screwed everything up! i want tennant back :,(

they are both epic, but i just think matts got the amazing but stupid and cool effect that he does!(like bowties, fezzes, setsons!) ;)

I like both Tennant and Smith. But I think Matt Smith never takes things really seriously and Is just jokes bowties and fezzes. While David Tennant was still comical time to time but still had a dark side and or serious side.
But anyways it really Is no contest David Tennant is the best doctor in all of Doctor who.
I love you David!