One pohon Hill's Purgatory Twist Remembered: 'Quinn and Clay Were Frolicking on the Beach, Dead!' 

Shantel VanSanten and Robert Buckley were (nearly) dead and loving it seven years ago when

Gossip Girl Turns 10: Faked Deaths, Fake Cousins, More OMFGG Twists

In the previous season’s finale, off-kilter stalker Katie Ryan (played by Amanda Schull) put bullets both in her prey Clay and his girlfriend Quinn. ‘Twas all but a bad dream, Clay realized as he and Quinn went for a stroll on the beach in the Season 8 premiere. Except… the shooting victims actually

, remembers worrying about her job security when filming the season-ending shooting. Addressing series boss Mark Schwahn at the time, “I was like, ‘Wait, are we

?\'” she recalls. “And he’s like, ‘No! You’re regulars on the show. Of

, we’re going to hang out in Purgatory??” With a laugh, she notes: “We’re frolicking on the beach and we don’t even realize we’re dead!”

Ally McBeal Turns 20: The Premiere’s Most ’90s Moments

Though quite unbelievable on paper, the double-episode storyline had an impact on viewers, despite the fact that Clay and Quinn had only been introduced the previous season. The actors involved meanwhile found real drama to mine from the surreal situation.

“It was really fun, and then it got to be really heartbreaking,” VanSanten shares, “when my character knew that she was going to be leaving Purgatory and entering her body [back in the hospital]. There was always stuff that we would do where we were like, ‘How the hell do you [act] this? This isn’t anything I could have ever experienced or know.’ But I think it led to some of the most emotional work that Rob and I really got to do, that entire season. I loved the perspective.”

Scandal Pop Quiz! How Well Do You Remember the Series’ Pilot?

revival movie ever comes to fruition, “I’m like, ‘Hell

I would do it.’ It was almost 10 years ago for me, so how fun would it be to all come back and see where they’d write us?”

“More than that,” she continues, “Rob is still my best friend, so to get to work with him again and reprise our roles would be awesome. It’s always fun to think about the good ol’ days!”

If you like TVLine, you\'ll LOVE our weekly newsletter. Click here to subscribe.

Ask Ausiello: Spoilers on Grey\'s, SVU, Teen Wolf, Riverdale, Supergirl, Suits, The Flash, Once, Last Man…

Arrowverse Crossover: Quantico\'s Russell Tovey Cast as Gay Superhero

Fuller House Creator: \'I\'ve Given Up Asking\' the Olsen Twins to Guest-Star

The Last Ship to End After Season 5? \'Far Too Early\' to Tell, TNT Responds

1Big Brother Finale Recap: Which Houseguest Won Season 19?387

2America\'s Got Talent Finale Recap: Did the Right Act Win Season 12?190

3Law & Order Vet Sam Waterston to Bring Jack McCoy to SVU Season 1996

4Big Brother\'s Celebrity Edition: Get In Your Official Cast…87

5Fall TV Predictions: Lost Spinoff, Super This Is Us Plan, Rent Meets…54