jawab pertanyaan ini

Atheism Pertanyaan

Soul?

Do anda belive we have a soul atau not? How exactly is soul even defined? I often get that soul has been measured atau something, but never how and where, do anda have any information on this? How would anda explain spiritualsm without soul? Fell free to post anything (at least kinda) related to the topic.

I personally think we do not have a soul and our fellings and thoughts are produced in brain. But that might be just me, since a am a ginger lol.
*
I know this pertanyaan is a bit random. I don't quite know what I was trying to ask oleh myself.
ilovereading posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu
 ilovereading posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu
next question »

Atheism Jawaban

misanthrope86 said:
Again, should be a forum topic...

The soul is a tricky concept. Personally, I think we have an "essence" about us. There is a core to who we are. Whether that is a literal core, as in a tangible soul, atau if it is just a feeling we get because we feel the need to explain our feeling that we are special, unique individuals, I don't know.

I too feel that the lebih likely explanation is that our brains are just interpreting our outer worlds and our inner worlds and trying to consolidate them and explain them.
But where my ideas butt-heads is when I think about ghosts etc. Logically, I am aware that the experience of a ghost is just my brain processing my emotions and creating the image atau sense of a ghost in order to express those emotions. Logically, I know that standing in a room where someone died and feeling a presence is my own brain doing the same kind of emotional processing. BUT there is something about those experiences that has always made me doubt my thoughts about what a soul is. The feeling that those souls in someway are still existing in some other form is overwhelming. So while all I have ever learnt has taught me that my brain is just organiating stimultion, the actual experience of those things really tests that knowledge. I still think seeing a ghost atau feeling a spirit is a brain going into emotional over-drive, but there is a part of me that believes that the essence of a person may continue existing, whether it is incorporated into another being atau soul (ie reincarnation) atau imprints itself upon an object atau within a certain space.
And for the record, in case someone asks, just because I believe in the possiblity of a soul in some form does not mean that I think that that soul could go to a heaven atau a hell. Heaven and hell are political constructions created for political purposes. Hell, so is the soul for that matter.
select as best answer
posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu 
pandawinx said:
Depends what anda mean oleh "soul".

If anda mean like malaikat carry anda up to heaven, your soul can be pocessed kind of sutff, then no.
But no matter weather christian, jewish, agnostic, athiest etc, anda can always know when somethings alive. When something's dead (and we've all seen a dead something before, maybe a luak, lumba-lumba on the side of the road :( atau on tv atau whatever) anda can see it is lacking a energy it has when it's alive. It's not the same anymore. But it's still there's. I believe that theres a energy we all pocess (from a athiest) which isn't there when your dead. Can anda tell the difference between a dead thing and a living thing?

Now, i'm not saying that we all have these magical blue heavenly stars atau any of that, i just well, wonder sometimes....
select as best answer
posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu 
mina_sit said:
this is one of the forever tidak terjawab questions. no one succeded to describe what soul exacly is. personally i believe that soul is a part of you, your characteristics and nothing supernatural atau paranormal...
ps: sorry for my english, they suck almost all the time...
select as best answer
posted lebih dari setahun yang lalu 
next question »