Pinkie Pie bounced around Ponyville on a natal Eve. She smiled as everypony greeted her. She gave everypony a gift. "Here is your gift, Ms. Cheerilee!" Pinkie Pie berkata with enthusiasm. Ms. Cheerilee gasped and said, "Thank you, Pinkie Pie! I'll be sure to open it tomorrow." She said. Pinkie Pie said, "I'll be happy to give any of my friends gifts!" That included everybody in Ponyville, because they all knew she was a great friend.

Pinkie Pie was just finishing up. "Thank anda so much, Pinkie! This gem is very radiant and beautiful!" Rarity said, beaming at the nice red gem. Pinkie Pie smiled and said, "It was nothing Rarity, even though I had to climb a mountain, stop an avalanche, calm down a dragon, throw a party for it, and find it! Bye!" She left and hopped to Dicord's statue...

Pinkie Pie stood there, looking up to him. She giggles and left a present in front of him, a letter included.

Dear Discord,

Thanks for all those good times we had! I mean, come on, cokelat rain! Don't forget those yummy cotton permen clouds! I will never forget it!

~ Pinkie Pie

She then hopped back to Sugarcube Corner. Discord moved his eyes and used his magic to pick up the letter. He read it and smiled.

The selanjutnya Christmas, Pinkie Pie woke up. She went downstairs to have breakfast. She looked out the window and gasped. "CHOCOLATE RAIN!" She shouted, running outside. Discord smiled as he saw her running and sticking out her tongue for the rain. She went up to him, Discord still frozen. "Thank you!"