This answer can go in many different directions. As far as dancing Victoria take this hands down. She has her solo done at the end of The invitation to the jellicle ball. Where Jemima has her own piece of dance but not so big. She lebih fits in the group as a dancer. Jemima has a beautiful voice over her dancing abilities. Moments of Happiness shows this verwell. As well as her small part in Memory.. Also each cat has her own different role. Both being kittens They helped Grizabella be accepted. Jemima understood Grizabellas message and told it in her own words. WhereVictoria was willing to actual acept Grizabella. She was the one who actualy tried to make contact with Grizabella. While Jemima told overey one in a much simpler form what Grizabellas message was and what Grizabella was actualy going through in her life.
Okkk, Iv thought this over, and came up with a better explination.
Victoria: Victoria is a cat that sometimes I really cinta her, and somtimes I HATE her. I dont like how she hogs the Camra so much, and has ohhh so many Solos, Also shes paired with sooo many diff kucing in the fanbase(more then any other cat, this makes me think she is Hoe-ish, Does she dance as sexualy with everyone the way she did Plato? Gross! :S), i think she has the potencial to be a complete and total Mary-sue.(I hate Mary-sues)
Jemima: I Honestly dident even know who she was the first few times i watched the DVD, She dosent dance very much,Her Voice is pretty (even if she does have a dubed voice) its a plus that she dose both, unlike Victoria who dosent have one solo song, Jemima sings and dances.(its better to be okk at everything, then just great at one thing.) I never really hate Jemima, but shes also never my fav.
I Guess They would both be Equal- since the love&hatetred for Victoria Ballance it out.
Electra and Etcetera are both better to me, they seem lebih real and fun. (I dont think anyone would consider them pefect) they have their good and bad traits, that mnakes me cinta them :)
BTW what is with all the fights over what one of the girls is better? one is a Dancer, one is a Singer anda cant compare the two. Like compareing a picture to a song xD