Carlisle is a cooler dad but charlie i think is better supportive wise.

yea i agree with emmett carlises relly cool but charlie was a real father.

it would be sooo cool to have carlisle as a dad

i couldnt pick , there both really really great , Carlisle is just plain awesome & Charlie's always there and supports Bella with everything :)

I agree with everyone. I guess Carlisle isnt as supportive as Charlie because his family is basically adults and they can make their own decisions.

Definatly Carlisle :)

He's sooo understanding

carlisle is so cool but charlie wants the best for his daughter wish there was a in between choice

i think carlisle has an easier job than charlie

thanks for all your comment i also think both dads would be really cool so thank for all you said