Well, realistically, if Edward wasn't a vampire, he'd be dead so she would HAVE to have chosen Jacob!
But, if they were both human, she'd still choose Edward, I think because she loved him despite the vampire thing and she never really thought about it too much, also, they would be able to do the things they couldn't do, like the whole intense ciuman thing without Edward pulling away... She still would have wanted to be friends with Jacob though.
I'd choose Jacob. Edward is too perfect and who'd want perfection. Jacob gets Bella inside out and he's the one that made her feel alive agin after Edward left her and remember when she berkata "When I'm with Jacob the hole doesn't exist.
Actually I would definitely choose Jacob, not choosin' oleh their phisical appearance but oleh their psyche. Jake is someone who U can rely on, who doesn't judge, who is protective but not over protective (like Ed, personally I would be bothered if I had a "father" for a boyfriend), he is someone with whom U can do something reckless and have a good laugh 'bout it afterwards, when he wants something he doesn't give up so easily (we girls sometimes like to be fought for), he is funny and makes U laugh...Edward on the other hand is full of melancholy, kinda predictable, kinda boring, sometimes in life U need to have some fun, he gives up easily...Ater all this is only my opinion, in the end it all depends on our likes and dislikes, we're not all the same and we all have different tampilan on how life should be.
i would choose edward even though i cinta jacob so much and he is so freakin hot edward is caring and so selfless he is a very loving person and he would die for bella no matter what he was da one dat went to commit suicide coz he thought the cinta of his life was dead and he does anything for the one he loves even if it hurts him alot