I would read the book first. The book is always better than the movie, not just in the case of twilight. I enjoy membaca buku so much lebih when I don't know what is going to happen. Besides, its always better to imagine it yourself before the movie ruins it for anda :)
well, i watched the movie first, and i thought it was great. the selanjutnya hari i went and bought twilight and read it. I reread, then went to see the movie again with my friend, and it wasn't as great, because i knew what was coming, and i was complaining about bits they didn't put in. I would vote see movie first, for once, but it's up to you.
Seriously i am book nerd, so yeah anda might think i say read the books. But if anda havent started, then go and watch the movie first. Simple as that, anda might be dissapointed otherwise, cause anda have your own gambar about what people look like, what they talk like....things like that. if anda cant wait though till all film come out, then read the buku and then just dont expect too much from the film [and no, i am not a hater.- i loved the movie]
I read the twilight buku first but that was before the movie was even announced, but if i had to go back and re-do that again I would still read the buku first because the movie doesnt go into depth of whats happening as much as the book does and anda get to enjoy the book and the movie lebih this way :)
I think anda should read the book first.Because when anda read it first it is your imagination but if anda watch the movie before membaca buku when anda read it all anda can imagine will be the movie.And anda won't get the chance to compare them.
WATCH THE MOVIE FIRST!!! Since the buku are better than the movie, if anda see the movie first and anda really like it (you'll really like it just like me!) and start the buku after, you'll be even happier because the buku are better than the movie!!! In other words, if anda read the buku first and watch the movie after, since the buku are better anda may be disappointed (just a little bit) because anda expected something equal to the books... I know I'm not clear but anyways! All I'm saying is WATCH THE MOVIE, THEN READ THE BOOKS! I did that and I enjoyed it all!!!
ok the book first totally no doubt about it. but just make sure tht no1 besides u reads it now. WAY 2 MANY PPL R RDG IT AND PRETENDING 2 cinta IT JUST 2 FIT IN...UGH!!! i mean u can read it just dont give any1 else a reason 2.
I would DEFINETLY read the book first! I only say this because, I watched the movie first and now im done the buku but when i was membaca Twilight i was really bored because i already knew what was going to happen! And dont listen to everyone who says see the movie first so anda dont get disappointed because, Robert Pattinsons in it!! How could anda be disapointed oleh that!!, If anda watch the movie first its like membaca a book twice!! Trust me! Its a LOT better if anda read the book!
I think anda should always read the book before seeing the movie. That way you're going in the right order because the book came before the movie, therefore i think the membaca of the book should come before the watching.
i saw the movie first...and i was really pleased with it...then i read twilight and new moon... i thing that anda have to see the movie first because there are a lot lebih going on at the books..........
i watched the film first, and loved it, and then i bought all the buku and read them in a few weeks, and i prefere the buku to the film - the buku are amazing! but if i coulkd go back i would have read the buku first, because its harder to imagine the main characters yourself, after anda have already watched the actors. It's better to have your own imagination of the main characters first i think =]
I always prefer to see the movie first, than to read the book: 1. the movie is suprising than and anda don't know what will happen next 2. when anda read the book afterwords anda see all the tiny details about the character and I think it's so great but it's only my point of view so...
I read the buku first, but I took my friend to see the movie before she read the buku and she got into it straight away. If anda are a visual person i would go and watch the movie, i like to do that when a new book to screen adaptation comes out cos anda can visualise the places and characters better. Also, if anda see the movie first anda wont be as disappointed. Overall, anda should do what anda think.
I would say read the series atau the book first then see the movie. But if u want to be carfull and not be disapointed when seeing the movie read it after.But really either way ur probably going to be disapointed,if they mess atau fuck with the movie.But again i would read the book first bacause i want to/bacause i already read the series and with the first movie they disorderd a lot of things but again thats just my opinion!!!!!
I enjoy membaca buku first (before the movies) with any series. Typiclly (and in the case of the Twilight Series,) the buku are much better then the film because of all the details. It's also better to read the book first because it's fun picturing the characters and later comparing them to the movie. If anda watch the movie anda have no imagination for what everything looks like.
membaca the buku first allows for lebih creativity and lebih enjoyment out of membaca the books. (When membaca first anda can't put the buku down because anda want to know what happens.)
I would watch the movie first because then maybe anda would like and not be disappointed oleh how it turned out on other hand if anda watch the movie they decide what your characters look like and their personalitys so its up to you=)
I wached the film first but I din't really follow it. after I read the buku now i'm on the last book. I think anda should read the book first atau if anda find it hard to follow things when anda fist watch them then I would watch the film first!
I would advise anda to read the book first because the story is explained much lebih (but that's just because they have to condense it down for the film) also because the characters go into much lebih depth especially Bella. Both the book and the film are really good, but anda really do look meneruskan, ke depan to seeing the movie after membaca the book, well I did anyway!=D But it's your choice whichever anda pick.=D
defenetly before!after the movie anda know what is going to happen and it's lost its magic , if anda know what i mean!i had already read the Twilight book until the baseball scene when i saw the movie an d i lost all the super book action!it;s really beautiful to read it from a book and really diferent from the movies!so i say , the book first!
yea i would read all the buku before anda see the movies, thats what my girl friend is doing before she watch the movie for the first time so i say read beofre watch with all the film cause it is nice to get all your thoughts and stuff in your head befor the movie.
anda should watch the movie first!! that way ur not dissapointed! I wish I saw the movie first and then read the books, the movie left out so many parts and they changed parts too!! I kept on saying thats not what happened in the book atau they left out this part...so ya I would watch the movie first!
Read,Read,Read away my friend.YOu are not going to be dissapointed unless anda have no paulse.I find that most people who find this a bit bland for a buku about endless cinta is a bit cynical and they might not have been truly loved.So I would suggest read it and I know that anda are going to cinta it!
I'd read the book. Its a lot better than the movie. (Than again, isn't it always that way?) Well, read the book. Not to say the movie isn't great. They both are good, but I'm not a huge Robert Pattinson fan.
I read the book first and was prepared for a rubbish comparison for the movie... BUT the movie is great- maybe not as good as the book but still amazing and I even saw it again... and again... and again... and again... AND again. All for the price of one lol. Oh yeah but read th book first cos once, i watched the movie wiv a frend and sometimes she didn't no wa was goin on so i had to tell her (roll eyes) but yu can do wa yu want relly.
watch the movie then read. The movie was kind of dissapointing cuz when anda read anda have favorit parts and they dont put all of your favorit parts in it. Also because anda know whats going to happen and it takes all of the surprise out. And think everyone knows thats never fun.
watch the movie first then read bcuz wen anda read it anda will remember parts from the movie and anda will be able to see the scenes in ur head better and anda will know what the characters look like and what they sound like
READ THE BOOK!!! I had a friend who saw the movie be4 she read the buku and she had no clue what was happening the whole time. they left out a LOT in the movie thats not in the book so the movie is kind of choopy and fast pace anda have to have read the buku to really get the movie and enjoy it.
In my personal opinion i would read first because if anda watch the movie first anda are greatly confused when anda read the book, my friend had to ask me so many pertanyaan about why the heck this was happening when it didn't happen in the movie, so unless your amazing and think anda can do it go for it. PS: i read a little above college level so i think anda should take my advice.
I say that anda should read the buku first. Sure, The movie is amazing, but they didn't put a lot of cool things in the movie that was in the book. So ya read the buku first (even Twilight, cause they took out some good stuff)
anda should read the book first because then anda will understand the storyline alot better. but when anda watch the movie, yo will realize that it sucks compared to the book. they took out alot of parts.
I normally read the buku first when it comes to ones that have been made into film however this time i deviated from and watched the movie first and after watching the movie it made me want to read the buku even more. As of this posting i have reread the buku lebih than i have re-watched the movie, but it really all comes down to your personal choice.
Read the book, for your own good.theres thing that were in the book but not in the movie. The book is always better, especially compared to the movie.I mean, i loved the movie but THE BOOK IS ALWAYS BETTER.
It depends on you, because if you're a movie sort of person, anda can start on the movie first then the book. But then when anda start the book first anda would have the facts in the movie and the lebih anda can understand the movie.
But in some movies, they cut some important parts and if anda start with movie anda wouldn't enjoy the book much because anda would like predict what is going to happen and there's not much excitement in that. So I suggest that anda read the book first.
Definitely the book series. atau at least the first book. The movie isn't even particularly good. Any movie with Edward Cullen is automatically the best movie in the world (O.K, serious contradiction), but they were working with a low budget, some low grade actors (by that I don't mean they're not good, just not famous)...Anyway, anda gotta read the book first.
The buku first so anda will understand the movie better. that way anda won't be watching trying to figure out why the characters are doing what they do. but, anda might not like the movie afteer the buku because they don't go oleh the book exactly, which is annoying if anda fall in cinta wth the books. When I saw the trailer for New Moon, I go t a little aggravated with the way they had manipulated some of the scenes. it will be lebih interesting to anda if anda invision the characters, etc. in your mind before anda try to adapt to the movie. anda may not like the actors they chose for the characters. for example, I was not really crazy about Kristen Stewart as Bella and I'm still not, but its up to you.
omg before! i can never stress enough that the imagination is the most amazing thing ever. but the mind is smart. so if u watch the movie first your mind will always subconciously carry the gambar from the movie, so then, the way anda c the book will almost be like a fog over how ur imagination would hav originally seen the characters and the plot
I know that many people would say read the book first. I disagree with this for one main reason. If anda read the book first, anda get these gambar in your head that are ruined when anda see the movie so if anda watch the movie first, anda can picture the actors of the movie and just have the gambar there so it doesn't ruin it for you. I watched the movie first and it didn't reck the book at all for me.
I would definately say watch the film first. I do this all the time because I am a visual learner.I like knowing how the scenes and characters look, so when I read the novels I can picture the actual scenes from the movie. It's awesome!
Always read the book first. I have found that people who have read the book didnt enjoy the film as much but not the other way round though. Despite this I would still read the book first if I were anda :D
I really recommend anda to read the buku first they are waaaay much better than the film and full of details that make anda understand the characters lebih than the film not to mention a lot of events are not even on the film so READ THE buku they are so much fun
Well, this is my own opinion...not sure if anyone has put it atau not :S But, oh well. Well, I think anda should definately read the buku first! I read Twilight a week before the film came out in cinemas then read the rest after. :) & trust me it really helped! Sure I was a little disapointed and kept thinking about them skipping parts and stuff but oh well...you can't fit everything in it. But, it really helped me too see what the setting was like and the characters looked like before I read the book, so I could make an image in my head while I was reading. Plus, I went to go see it with my friends and one of them had never read Twilight and the hole time through the film she kept asking me about stuff 'cause she didn't really understand. So, I had to explain it to her -.- which was pretty annoying!!! lmao. So, definately read it before the film. :) & it was a tad boring at the start but keep membaca it gets AMAZING! aha. Enjoy. :)
i must admit i saw the movie first and i made me not want to read the first book, so what i did was i went out and bought all of them from first through fourth and broke down and read it from start to finish... it made the movie better to me because when i watch it seemed like the whole relationship between Bella and Edward went a little fast, but after membaca the book i was able pick out certain things ( of course) but i was also able to visualize (through the book) why their relationship grew like it did... so for me watching the movie first didn't hurt but helped me get into the buku themselves because after watching the movie it made me want to know how it ended for them.
Im starting to think that Watching the Movie will be best... I never read the book before I watched it and was gripped oleh it from the detik the dialogue started...I then bought the DVD and quickly became obsessed while I waited for my Book Box set to arrive...20 days later... I then Rushed to read Twilight.. and loved every detik of it.. I even enjoyed the differences because it added depth and another dimention for me, because there were mini stories within the story,And so it was exciting and I loved every page...And I couldnt wait to read New Moon... But now I have...Thank goodness I stopped there, Because now i know what will happen in the Movie... Which saddens me because I am a Movie Fanatic, and I cinta being totally engrossed in a Movie, and feeling all the feelings and confusion and pase that goes along with it... But when anda know how it will end...doesnt that spoil it for you? So... What I am doing is waiting for New Moon - I will watch it - and then decide if I will finnishe the buku before Watching the rest of the movies...
Somehow I honestly believe WATCHING these specific film first is the Right way to do this... Then go deeper...Read it at leisure...
And besides, Its so much nicer to have gambar of Edward Cullen in my head (of Robert Pattinson) than to have imagined him any other way... And the Soundtrack is so captivating, I can hear it in my head while membaca it...and long after...
read the buku first becasue i started readin twilight then watched the movie and i never finished twilight i mean i've read it all a couple of times know but its puts anda off klnowing what will happen even if anda do know its better readin the buku 1st
anda should do what ever anda think is best.my mom always told me that i should read the buku before i watched the film so i would probaly not ask her what would happen,but on the other hand i could tell her everything well i have to go to tell my mom that but u should still do what ever u want.love heather
I would definitely say watch the film first. Seeing as Twilight is still the only one out first, watch the Twilight and New Moon film first then go ahead and read the Saga books. It will only increase your cinta for the Saga! When anda read the book first then see the movie, the movie usually turns out as a huge disappointment compared to the book.
anda should really see the movie first... anda will cinta it!!! and then, when anda read the books, you'll think the're perfect and you'll cinta the series even more... The movie is good but it's not even half as good as the books... but you've probably already read the buku and seen the movie, right???:))
well actually it depends to anda but the book is really better and everything on it happens at the right time but the movie ,well has some diffrences ,so i recommened anda to read the book rst and detik watch the film , & do not worry anda will enjoy the film this way too.
The buku rock and anda always wish the book never ends but the film don't give anda the same feeling. I watched Twilight first and I fell in cinta with Rob Pattinson as Edward and when I read the book after I thought Kristen wasn't as warm and sweet as the Bella in the book so I was disappointed.And then I had difficulty imagining my own Edward and Bella,actually the whole cast except Jacob. Oh and my Rosalie was somewhat closer to Claudia Schiffer in looks. anda should beruang in mind that everything is so minimized in the movies.The really romantic scenes are cut short.
Well my opinion i was exactly like anda i didnt no if i should read them atau not but i really wanted to so i did & when i watched new moon if anda read the book certain things bella says people who havent read the book dont understand but if anda do u can fill in the gaps if u no wat i mean & im officailly a twilighter now i finished the saga last bulan :) and ive got the host for xmas :D i hope stephanie finishes midnight sun ! :) so yeah if i was anda i would read them
I think anda should read the book first. I watched the movie first and i thought it wasnt so great like everybody else said. Then i read the buku and i totally loved it. Its absolutly different, even though the movie is well adapted and its nice to watch it after knowing the story
Before. You'll understand the film better. The twilight one was crappily thrown together. And the New Moon one was good, but during some parts it would've been hard for me to understand what was going on if I hadn't read the book first.
Read the book before the movie so anda will get a better understanding of what's going on, especiallly if you're seeing New Moon and haven't seen Twilight (but who hasn't seen it, right?). If anda haven't read the story, the main details won't be understood, and you'll practically miss the main part.
It would also be a good idea to keep on membaca the series afterward so when the other film come, this won't happen again. Oh, BTW, June 30, 2010= Eclipse, BABY!
They are dead big but it's kind of like Harry Potter they leave out bits and if anda read the buku first anda may understand it better. but make sure anda do read the buku in order obviously, becasue otherwise anda haven't got a clue what's going on.
ok~ i would defiantly read the buku first, even if your not a reader. anda will end up getting so caught up in the story they will be hard to put down. in my opinion, while the film are defiantly GREAT they left so much of the buku out of them, & i understand why they had to do that cause of time restrictions etc. but still. anda need to read the books. my friend wanted to go & see new moon. i had not even read the buku atau seen twilight. so i went along, totally not having any idea of the story. took me a while to get into new moon. but once i did i loved it & strait after the movie went & bought the twilight dvd. watched that, then my sister mentioned she had the books. so after watching both film i then read the books. i understood the story so much better once i finished them. i did everything backwards, which i regret. so, my saran to anda would be to DEFIANTLY read the buku first.. do that BEFORE any tv tampil atau movie comes out of that series your reading!
u should sooo read the book first cuz the book is soo much better than the movie. . .at lest twilight. i really didnt like the pindah twilight, but i think it was cuz of the director. but i really like new moon the movie!! but u know. . .ppl have their own tastes soo......
If anda like reding buku anda have to read buku first. But if anda like films anda should watch film first. But if I were anda I will read books. It is lebih exsiting and anda learn lebih things. Read buku first!!!
Thats kind of tough because if anda read the buku first then the film will most likely disappoint you, but if anda watch the film first then anda may get bored membaca the books... I read all the buku first& thats how I fell in cinta <3
some ppl say if u read the buku be4 u will know what happens but the film and the buku will never be exactly alike because if they had to put everything in buku in the film they would have a 3 hr atau longer movie so read the buku 1st then watch the movie since eclipse insnt gonna be in theatres for a while
well i saw twilight befor i read da buku but my sister told me how great the buku were so i just read twilight and i fell in cinta so then i couldnt help my self so i read all the buku i thikn anda should read the buku becuasse they give anda much lebih infomrtaion and are way better then the film and in it anda really see how much cinta edward and bella have
anda SHOULD DIFFENTLY READ IT BEFORE anda SEE THE MOVIES. THAT WAY anda CAN PICTURE BELLA THE WAY THEY HAVE HER IN THE BOOK. THE DOWNSIDE AFTER membaca THE buku anda MIGHT BE DISAPPOINTED IN THE MOVIE. BUT I WOULD DIFFENTLY READ IT BEFORE THE MOVIES!!!
Read the book. anda Don't want it to be diberikan away do you? It would so much less exciting that way. I read the buku a million times and I think they're better than the film so youy should read the buku and then watch the movies. That way anda can complain about it and act like anda know everything lol!
I am membaca the 3rd book right now and when i was finishing twilight i went to the film to see New Moon, once i started membaca new moon, i thought that the buku are better than the movies. so anda should start with the books.
anda should read the book first because if u watch the movie then it ruins the gambar in your head but if anda read the book first anda can imagine things your way and make it lebih exciting xD thats what i did xx
i think u should read first because it would make lebih sence when u see the movie. If u see the movie first it would be a spolier to u. So read the book first then see the movie thats what i did and the movie made sence to me after because i read.
Read the buku first... anda can understand a lot more, when u watch the movie.. Like, when anda read the books, anda will definitely be in your dream world, imagining everything.. When anda watch it, anda can enjoy your imaginations as well as the movie.. If anda watch the movie first, anda would miss a lot of things covered in the book.. Movie is just like a cuplikan of the book.. Movie is just not so deep as the book!
I think should read the buku first yeah anda knows what's going to happen anda will be closer to Bella. It will be easier to understand. And on the plus side anda yell at the screen when they get it wrong thats what I do. With all buku turned movies.
I watched Twilight first, and am really happy I did. membaca Twilight (and each subsequent book) is much lebih enjoyable when anda have faces and voices to put with the characters. Also, I found I was able to better absorb little details in Twilight I might have otherwise missed had I been trying to piece together the larger story. I should mention though, the other buku are much better than the film so my recommendation is to watch Twilight, then read the entire series. Hope this helps :)
its good to read the buku first coz anda get a better understanding of the storyline. i havent read the buku coz i cant be stuffed but my personal oppinion is read the buku first. In the film they tend to change some parts. So when anda read, anda understand more. i THINK im repeating myself, oh well:)
I say read the buku first so anda can enjoy the story without knowing whats gonna happen (its sort of a waste to read a book if u already know the ending) and then u can enjoy watching how it plays out in the movie.
Most people who cinta twilight, only cinta robbert and taylor. I don't. I cinta the books. I cinta the way it's written, the way it makes me think about my own live, and what I should do better for my loved ones. Iris: I think anda shouldn't watch the movies. If anda want to, please, first the books! the movie makes a whole difference. The movie don't makes anda think, it makes anda brainless. To eveyone who only loves the twilight mvies, Think about what anda like. Do anda like robbert pattinson, atau do anda cinta the storyline? If anda can answer this pertanyaan with the truth, oleh saying, I cinta the storyline, than at least you're heathy. Sure.. Robbert is hot, but hotness of a man is not something that should be the basics of if anda like a serie atau not.
read the book before watching. the book is thrilling and exotic enough danger to give anda chills, the movie is very beautiful though, the actors play briliantlu but i stand oleh my veridict to read the book first
I, personally, watched the film before membaca the books. However, in my opinion, the buku are just a little better, so I think anda would be able to enjoy the series lebih that way. If anda enjoy the books, you'll cinta the movies.
if u wanna fully enjoy the film u should watch the film first and then read the buku because they leave alot out of the film and u will be mad about that i was so i would just enjoy the movie and then bask in the cinta in the book that much more!
after cuz u know what the movie is but not the book and u r able 2 visualize the menulis better and it seems like u r watching the movie and u can really point out the deleted sceens and the extras and how they r similar and how they r different
I would watch it first - I always like membaca the book after because it feels like going behind the scenes in a way because anda learn lebih about all the characters - it's like watching deleted scenes in your head :)
It really just depends on you. Do anda normally read a book series first atau watch the films/TV series based on them? If anda read the buku first, do anda find yourself getting irritated oleh any parts which get omitted atau changed? Does seeing the films first affect your ability to imagine the characters and scenes your own way?
I read the first book then saw the first film before membaca the rest of series. I enjoyed them that way, but I think I'd have enjoyed as much if I'd read all the buku first, atau watched all the films first. They stay pretty true to the buku (or true enough not to irritate me, anyway, unlike certain other series). The films tell the story well enough that I think people could follow it without needing to read the buku first. But then there's one scene which is changed and I think the change was lebih shocking and had lebih impact for me because I'd read that part of the book and was expecting it to stick to canon (trying to be vague so that if anda read the buku first, anda might be shocked in the same way).