I was heartbroken and mad! i was mad at peyton NOT for telling her the truth but for promising not to hurt her again after the shooting and then hurting her soo much.Brooke wasnt mad at her telling the truth but she was heartbroken and hurt from peyton! It was her best friend,TWICE she did that to brooke!! I was mad because at peyton for doing all of the above stuff i just said ^^

Chlarkfan, all you ever do is blame Peyton and you never talk about anything else on OTH. Brooke slept with Nathan even though he dated her supposed best friend. She also slept with Chris even though she was supposedly in love with Lucas. Peyton made a mistake but she made those mistakes because she was in love. Brooke did things to hurt people.

SERIOUSLY it`s SO true, Chlarkfan you`re AN ASS! I swear you don`t get the show, stick to watching hannah montana for now =) Peyton had Lucas first, we get she turned him down but that was a mistake she realized pretty quick! Brooke was fully aware that they had feelings for eachother but dove in pretty quick, don`tcha think? The first time, it was her actions just having consequences! Second time, it`s not called "cheating". I`m sure you didn`t seem to mind in Smallville when Jimmy & Chloe thought they would die & kissed- IT`S JUST LIKE THAT but peyton & lucas are hotter & she was already shot! BTW, Brooke hurt Peyton quite a few times. "You killed you moms" or w/e is WAY out of line & that`s coming from me . Also, Brooke slept w// Peyton`s boyfriend & Peyton did SO much for Nathan, she stayed a cheerleader just for him . & despite all Brooke`s mistakes, I still love her . None of us are assholes like you & seeing as how breyton are best friends and totally over eachother`s past mistakes, we should be too.

I honestly didn't care. all I new was that Brooke and Lucas aren't ending up together as much I hate to admit it.

Ohh god here we go again...ok chlarkfan..your a great friend and all, but Lila and kathiria are soo right..you really need to take some time and watch the whole show from 1-4 and then come back and tell me was peyton the only one who hurt brooke?...was peyton the only one who cheated?....was peyton the only one who lied to brooke?..was peyton the only one who betryed brooke?...i mean seriously i can go on with these questions, but why bother when all these questions have the same answer..which is NO peyton wasn't the only one! You go around and keep saying peyton did this to brooke..peyton did that...but my question is...Where's lucas name?? What about lucas??...you know the guy you say is the the "ONE" for brooke..the guy who cheated,hurt,betryed and lied to brooke...i mean i unerstand that peyton is brooke's BFF, but that's no excuse to just let luke off the hook and dump everything on peyton! After the sex tape i never dumped everything on brooke i also blame nathan even tho we all know nate was an ass back than (lol). I blamed both, but after the ST happened i got over it, but what i liked was that after the ST nate actually took full responsibility for it even tho it was 2 yrs ago...kinda like what peyt did (minus the 2 yrs ago). I mean brooke she hid from it, she didn't take full responsibility for it kinda like what luke did(w/ the whole cheating)...Wow maybe brucas are similar in some ways=]! Anyways my point is if your gonna blame the cheating on peyton than you have to blame luke as well cuz he was part of it! Even the kissing scene in the library!

I agree with all the ppl who defended peyton and added other characters to the mix when it came to faults. chlarkfan, your opinion against peyton is biast at best. you are one-tracked with the peyton hating campaign and you need to stop. if you're gonna rag on peyton, you'd better rag on brooke, nate, and luke twice as much. I think the fans who posted their comments in peyton's defense have stolen the words from my mouth. but i just wanna add this: I "objectively" think that peyton and luke's kiss in the library wasn't a romantic moment. peyton was about to die and that kiss was about a love btw friends. and although I would have been mad like brooke was, I would have realized the circumstances and believed luke when he said it was not a romantic moment. I do understand that since leyton had a past, it makes it more difficult to trust what luke is saying. but I'm speaking from an objective point of view. I don't see the library leyton kiss as a second betrayal. I can't wait to see leyton back together someday in S5.

none of the above? Brooke blew it just as much as she did.

yeah i agree none of the above! Breyton hurt eachother Breyton not only Peyton hurt Brooke, Brooke hurt Peyton too! so i cant belive what u are saying chlarkfan!

Peyton told Brooke she loved Lucas, however despite the fact that she loved Lucas she wouldn't tell him unless Brooke and him where over. How is that blowing it? Okay i admit she kissed him which isn't good but to be fair, bullet wound, bleeding to death surely that matters?
To quote Rachel "sounds like a pretty great friend"
Peyton felt horrible about loving Lucas the first time round she told him she couldn't do that to Brooke because Brooke ment to much to her. Lucas was the one who kept saying he needed to be with her, while he was going out with Brooke!
Peyton even tried although she didn't want to, to get lucas and brooke back together with the birthday thing but it didn't work.

I know Peyton made mistakes but only the first time was bad the second time i think she was really good about it and tried to be a really good friend despite her love for lucas. Where as Brooke clearly was trying to hurt peyton with the mom's death comment, which was horrible.

But they're amazing best friends and thats the way it should be, so it's all good now! =D

Basically agree with abs07 lol

Ok look im just wondering what you felt i'll add that you can add your opinions im sorry if i offended you guys i was just wondering how you guys felt

chlarkfan, sorry if you feel attacked, but this was not your only poll/comment posted about peyton. you've had numerous bias peyton hating crusades when brooke has done worse; that's why alota fans are fed up and have had heated opinions against yours. Now I'm not a fan of brooke's...at all...but I'm not constantly making polls and posting hateful comments about her. she's not the only one who's screwed up over the seasons. if you tried to approach the storyline/characters more holistically (try and look at both sides of situations), I think ppl would respect your opinions more. =)

i was upset but not heartbroken i was mad at peyton I love BRUCAS

hahaha... is this a rollercoaster ride or a never ending story...
plsss... for christ sake get over it, MOOOOVE OOOOON.....

haha, well put shingkai...

It was a big deal it ended the breyton friendship for a long time! And i LOVE BREYTON =]

it was such a good scene to me, brookes such a good actor it felt so real! i loved it when she goes " hes on the DAMN door peyton! under MY name!"

yer but the friendship is back and better so it doesnt matter as much! :P
theres so many people who made goods points - abs07,leytonfan4ever,SG1-090,kathiria82 and lila856
peyton didnt do anything wrong really when this happened!
she told brooke how she felt- which she cant help thats she fell inlove with lucas!
she wasnt gunna do anything about it! it was brooke that finished with luc then peyton tried to get them back together and then peyton told lucas how she felt!!

ok i admit it i got horny ^.^ =]

lmao i was soo happy! peyton did blow it. its like eveything that came out of her mouth was a lie, and i was glad brooke wasnt taking her BS anymore. it was good to see her tell peyton off, cuz honeslty peyton diserved it. not cuz she told her about her feelings, but she told brooke she would never do anything like this to her again. well that obviously was a lie! but yea i guess i was a little sad cuz they were bffs and it sucks seeing best friends fight, but then again it was still pretty awsome lmao.

I was mad ... at Brooke ;/

about time she got slapped

I was mad at Brooke.