for me i'd say keith. except from the dying part ofc. :p
i could've chosen larry, but he was always at work in different city's and countries. and i can't pick nathan. just the thought og being in love with your dad is freakin' me out! :o

He wasn´t related to Lucas by blood but he still stood around for him and treated him like a son for 17 years.

nathan or lucas.

nathan (:

Kristine i agree with you i would have some not so good thoughts if it was Nathan or Lucas for that matter.

he woulda been I know it.

After Nate's idiotic actions in s4 (gambling with loan sharks) and 5 (alcoholic self piteous violent phase), I can't say he's the model father, but he's a good one.

Luke's never really been in a position to be a father. He's babysat sometimes and helped raise Jamie in his first 4 years or whatever but we never got to see that.

Larry was pretty good but he was gone all the time.

Dan....well, the series speaks for itself. Dan is a legend. There should be a book written about his fatherhood - what NOT to do.

i would have to say keith. cause he had such a good impact of luke's life and wasn't even his father.
i agree with some of the comments above, i cant pick lucas or nathan cause the thought of being inlove with your father freaks me out.
larry is not the best, always away working and emm dan aint greatest either *understatement of the year* anyways :)

What about Jake?
He's definitely the best.
And Lucas isnt a father.

and his wife should be brooke

Right now I'd say Nathan, Keith was an amazing father to Lucas too and Jake to Jenny, no doubt that Lucas will be a great dad!!!