If some other actress instead of Emma had played Hermione in the movies,would her appeal be any less to you? Why?

Maybe, maybe not! I think Emma was great and we've senn her in the film for so long that it's difficult to imagine another hermione! But i think i would have liked harry potter less.

No. I like Hermione for her character(the way it is in the book). It wouldn't matter who played her.

She was fabulous,both in novel and movies.I can hardly think of anyone except her in the movies.

Less. I actually cant imagine anyone as Hermione besides Emma.

Well... If the actress was still just as bossy and smart as Emma's version, I think that I would have still liked the character... I dunno though. It is hard to imagine another Hermione!

Emma is perfect for the movie but since I prefer the buku anyways it wouldn't have mattered to me much.

Well, I don't think we would care too much if it started out with someone that wasn't Emma Watson. But if say, at the 5th movie (Order of the Phoenix) they had someone and then replaced her with Emma Watson, I think we would be upart because it would be a totally different Hermione. Same reverse way. But I think Emma Watson was an awesome Hermione anyway :)

I guess it depends. Although, I honestly think that I would like Harry Potter less.

yes I think so because she is my favourite actress in harry Potter and lot's of other movies

If since 2001, the actress is not Emma, i would admire, but if the actress replaced Emma, i would disagree

i dont no, cuz the thing is if we had a nother actress then we would have been use to them not emma... so it would have been like the same what if we had so and so and not emma?

i really can't imagine anyone else playing hermione. but if the actor was as good as emma i guess it wouldn't matter.

Not at all...I think she is a great person no matter what she does!!! I dont think that someone should judge anyone oleh the film they play in...

I can't imagine anyone else playing Hermione. Emma plays her spectacularly. She gives off that Hermione-ish vibe. So I think it might have a appealed me less.

I think the it would've mattered a little as Emma IS very much like Hermione....as per I think so and a great actress,but if it was not Emma and any other actress from the start then that's different.But still I think she is the only person most suitable to play the awesome role of Hermione Granger.
cinta Emma!