she was much more intelligent than the others....and her pictures were at least equal if not better than caridees

they were both amazing, but melrose did have a bit of an edge (even though she was a beotch)

I think CariDee's pictures were amazing, but Melrose's were also pretty goood.

both had great photos, but in the runway, cari sucked and melrose rocked

Not only that but they were all sooo mean to melrose.... i noticed people calling melrose a bitch but if you rewatch, they were all sooo mean to her!

they were i didn't think she was a bitch she was in a competition she wasn't there to make friends just because she wasn't as fake as everyone else and yes people were rude to her she really didn't do anything wrong I loved Caridee but she did have bitchy moment did you see her at the runway no one even seemed to use that against her and it was extremely bitchy of her and when the judges were talking about the winner they spoke of all the things Melrose brought about grrr i did love Caridee but i still think Melrose should have won

Melrose was the most honest out of the two
she went in there wanting to be a top model not everyone's best friend
She should have won
Carrie dee wasn't as good!

I know her pictures was pretty.... But I am really not that crasy about her face in the pictures... But its my style..

they r both beautiful, but i think caridee makes a better model, melrose looks a little bit old when u look at her up close.

still Caridee cause she is FRESH.

ilu cari

This pic of MelRose is not her best, but her body of work outshines CariDee, but CariDee did also do an amazing job, and surpassed MelRose's work on this photo. I like them both!